Park Tool's PCS-9 Home Mechanic Bicycle Repair Stand was and still is a popular repair stand. The PCS-10 came out later and is also scoring great reviews, if not better. I did a lot of research on the two in looking for which is the right stand to buy and here's a comparison for those doing the same thing or looking to buy a good bicycle repair stand.
Both are sturdy. You'll be surprised, they are more sturdy then they look in the pictures. Both their clamps will rotate 360 degrees, which allows you to rotate your bike to any angle while working on it. Both will adjust to the same height if desired, which is tall enough to meet your bicycle tinkering needs. Both fold up so that they can be put away or moved to another location more easily than the non-portable repair stands that may need a parking space in your garage. They can also both hold bikes with odd shaped tubing, if you happen to be one of them odd tubing kind of guys.
In short, PCS-10 is the same style of bicycle repair stand with all the same features but it's sporting some upgrades. Of course you gotta love upgrades. I try not to get too caught up in the bells and whistles on any next generation product unless I need them, but for the most part, I wouldn't say these new features fall fully into that category. The upgrades appear to have been well thought out to take a popular product of the PCS-9 and turning it into an even simpler and easier to use tool. Getting a sturdy bike repair stand is, in itself, already making life easier by far for your bicycle home repairs. The PCS-10 strives to do that even more.
Here's an evaluation of the upgrades to the PCS-10
1. Quick Release Clamp
With the PCS-9 repair stand, you have to hold the bike with one hand while slowly screwing the clamp closed. It's much easier and quicker with the single clamping action of the PCS-10. The quick release clamp also sports a couple good features of it's own that I feel are worth noting:
clamp pressure is fully adjustable
the jaw covers are replaceable, which basically means the PCS-10 should stand a good chance of lasting you through your biking life.
As one reviewer put it:
"I went ahead and chose this (PCS-10) over the less expensive Park Tool PCS-9 Home Mechanic Work Stand to get the quick-release clamps, which I recommend; after all, you want to spend your time working on the bike, not the stand, and getting back out on the road or trail, right? Every little bit of frustration and effort saved helps."
Fair enough.
2. More Portability
Both can be folded down to be put away and moved around, but the PCS-10 weighs a little less than the PCS-9, so it is a little more portable. Both are not as light as some bicycle repair stands can be, but the lighter ones will never be as sturdy and the heavier ones will never be as portable. So Park Tool tries to get a good balance with both these stands and do a great job. Little more so with the PCS-10.
3. Quick Release Height Adjustment
Again, makes things easier. Both stands will adjust to hold your bike quite high up if you want them to. The PCS-10 makes this adjustable action simpler since the PCS-9 uses a hex key for this action.
4. Little Extra Stability
Park Tool reinforced the center yolk in the PCS-10 for what they say is superior stability, and have added a sliding ring to lock the folding legs. This part is starting to feel a little like the bells and whistle but it can't hurt. If they've managed to make the PCS-10 a little more lighter and a lot more stable, then that is a great selling feature.
5. Price
You get what you pay for and of course the PCS-10 cost a little extra. Not a lot, but if your budget is tight then this would be the primary reason to get the PCS-9. If your squirming over whether to pay the few extra dollars, don't fret too much as the PCS-9 is a good sturdy stand. Otherwise the PCS-10 is the better and upgraded bicycle repair stand of the two options.
Learn much more about bike repair stands and find pictures and my comprehensive review of the Park Tool Bike Repair Stand.
No comments:
Post a Comment